About This Case

Closed

23 Oct 2007, 11:59PM PT

Bonus Detail

  • Top 3 Qualifying Insights Earn $100 Bonus

Posted

8 Oct 2007, 12:00AM PT

Industries

  • Advertising / Marketing / Sales
  • Consumer Services / Retail Industry
  • Hardware
  • Internet / Online Services / Consumer Software
  • Media / Entertainment
  • Start-Ups / Small Businesses / Franchises
  • Telecom / Broadband / Wireless

What If I Don't Want A Fancy Phone -- Just Some Fancy Features?

 

Closed: 23 Oct 2007, 11:59PM PT

Earn up to $100 for Insights on this case.

LetsTalk's PhoneTalk blog wants to add new voices to its website, and they're posting regular issues here for the Techdirt Insight Community to add interesting new content to their site. The winning submissions for each challenge issue will be posted (perhaps with some editing) on the PhoneTalk blog -- with credits to the author. The following is LetsTalk's next assignment:

Personal Information Management (PIM) functionality is a cornerstone of smartphones, and the ability to sync with users' PCs is a key selling point. But users of lower-end handsets are also interested in PIM features like calendars and better phonebooks -- even if their devices' native applications are limited. What are the alternatives for PIM software for users of "lesser" handsets -- be it installed Java or BREW applications, or web-based services? What are some of the best apps for calendaring, or for contact sync, backup and management?

3 Insights

 



Many of the lower-end Nokia devices support something called SyncML. This is built into the phone and can be used for syncing your contacts with a third party server, such as Schedule World or MightyPhone. While it does not enhance the calendar or contact management in the phone, it does provide a way to back up your contacts into the cloud or sync with other services. 

The Need for a Mobile Calendar   

There is a dramatic need for a mobile stub into the Google Calendar, for example.  All it would need to do is to display the google calendar entries, and to provide for simple navigation by the phone controls.  Adding events might be cumbersome due to the numeric-to-alpha entry issues many cellphones still have, but the ability to enter an event one time and see it "everywhere" would be worth the effort.  The calendar would not look ahead farther than i.e. a week, just to prevent the phone's mobile connection from eating up a ton of bandwidth and thus eating minutes.

I actually have one of the low end phones. It's the Virgin Mobile Oystr. Kycera makes it, not sure what the real model number is. You can do a lot already with the WAP browser and SMS. I can SMS my Google calendar and it immediately returns the day's schedule. I can also do it for at least 1 day looking forward. I can get to my Gmail account on the web browser too.

Almost anything that can be done on an IPhone can be done on just about any other mobile phone. It's not going to be as convenient, and certainly won't be as pretty to look at. But if you need access to data on the web, any WAP enabled phone can handle it.

Low end phones generally don't sync with a computer. However, if you sync your desktop applications to the web, all that data will be accessible via the WAP browser. All the major web mail options have a way to sync address books to your local PC. It's simple to route all your email through a web mail service like Gmail. Not only does it act as an automatic back up, it provides remote accessibility via the phone.

As a primarily "read" device, the low end phones are quite functional if you put some thought into how you can sync data to the web to make it accessible. As a "write" device, a tiny 12 key number pad is less than desirable. However, the never ending march of more features for less in mobile phones is solving that problem. Virgin Mobile has a new phone that provides a QWERTY keyboard, color screen, 1.3 MB camera and a bunch more. The retail price is $99.

In my view, web based applications are best because they will work the same from both the phone and a PC, and the web app will function as the sync point for the anything entered via phone or anything entered via PC. Also, relying on web based apps helps ensure that you don't get stuck with one wireless carrier just because you are hooked on a proprietary application available only in their phones. 12 months from now, the new Virgin smart phone will be on sale for $59 and within reach of just about anybody that wants or needs PIM type features in a wireless device.

 

Disclaimer: Contrary to the impression provided in this answer, I don't work for either Google or Virgin Mobile. I work for Techdirt and thus am not elgible for the payout.

icon
Dameon Welch-Abernathy
Tue Oct 23 2:58pm
My only comment about a lot of these web services on the lower-end phones is that they are beyond the realm of the average person. I could not get my wife to use a WAP/XHTML site for any reason whatsoever. Granted, it does make it easier to switch carriers to rely on web services, but the fact of the matter is, the mass market--the very market who typically buys the low-end devices--aren't going to want to have to deal with installing apps or even data services.

There are cable-sync solutions for customers who don't want a data plan. Many of Nokia's phones--even the low end ones--can sync PIM data with a cable and PC Suite.